[yODa]

If that were me I wouldnt kill him,I wouldnt have the heart to kill someone who didnt even attack me,it was a sad moment for me when i saw that cry: cry:

[HeadUp]

well he cracked that secure little grin, and winters jus popped one in him

[RandyShughart]

well anyways, let's not forget why i posted this forum lol

[yODa]

Originally Posted by RandyShughart

well anyways, let's not forget why i posted this forum lol

lol,yea way offtopic: ,but still i would of just tooken him as a pow not a corpse

[Tystnad]

Originally Posted by yODa

lol,yea way offtopic: ,but still i would of just tooken him as a pow not a corpse

Even if you suspected his m8's could be around the corner, and that he wouldve shouted a warning for them? eek:

[St@tIc]

the way i see it is if the kid is on the battlefield...with a uniform on he is a target.no matter the age.we had kids over there too.kids would lie about there ago.so winters did what he had to do

[yODa]

Well did the german kid shout for help? did he shoot?,No,and he had time to do somethin

[Tystnad]

Originally Posted by yODa

Well did the german kid shout for help? did he shoot?,No,and he had time to do somethin

Uhm.. Ever heard of shock? eek:

[yODa]

ah.. but the germans we're trained to expect everything,so how could he be in shock?

[yODa]

meh...forget about it its just documeantry anyway so i feel better rolleyes:

[St@tIc]

if its in the movie it prbly really happened,if u have the video tapes of bob watch the last one and u will hear winters saying that he felt bad after killin the kid

[HeadUp]

well he has this scared look on his face, and then he sees winters, and his expression changes to relief almost, i noticed that the first time i saw it

its such a strange scene

[yODa]

[quote="St@tIc":b6129]if its in the movie it prbly really happened,if u have the video tapes of bob watch the last one and u will hear winters saying that he felt bad after killin the kid[/quote:b6129]yea,thatw here i saw him shoot the german,i didnt see all the episodes HBo dosent know what it has it could get good raiting if if they show it agian,BTW are they making a new documeantry about ww2?

[RandyShughart]

ok, i dont mean to be rude, but some of you forgot why i posted this topic...i need a skin of that kid, or at least his uniform.

offtopic: i think that that kid almost thought he was safe going into American hands...Winters made a split second decision, one that could've ended his life had that kid shouted alarm, and in my opinion, he chose right. if he hadn't, he may be dead now.

[St@tIc]

all i kno is that if i where there i would have done the same thing.1 less german=faster way to get home