[Coleman]

I think stickies are meant for threads that have good content but don't have a lot of posts frequently. The photography thread is good as a sticky because posts aren't made every day on it, yet it has quality content. The gif thread, in my opinion, shouldn't be a sticky because people make posts in it at a higher frequency than the photography thread. If a post is made on it, it'll come back up to the top, saving it from moving to the backpages. Desktop thread...who cares. Scrap it.

In conclusion, if a thread is popular enough (post wise) then the thread should save itself from moving to other pages. A sticky is for protection for threads with good content so it doesn't get lost.